January 30th, 2010 
Money maker
Mistakes are costly in do-it-yourself investing, and never mind your bad stock and fund picks.
You opened a small registered retirement savings plan account with an online broker without checking its annual administration fees? Ka-ching. That could cost you $100 per year. You chose a broker without really checking it out, and now you want to move? Ka-ching. That could cost you as much as $135.
In the online brokerage business, small investors too often pay big fees. Fight back by consulting the Portfolio Strategy column’s second annual roundup of fees for online brokerage registered accounts.
Low fees are a foundation of effective do-it-yourself investing, but they’re not the only factor in choosing a broker. For more commentary on the 12 firms listed here, check out the Globe and Mail’s current ranking of online brokers.
The DIY Investor’s Ultimate Registered Account Fee Guide
| Here’s a comparison of fees and commissions charged by 12 online brokerages for self-directed registered retirement savings plans, registered retirement income funds, tax-free savings accounts and registered education savings plans. All costs apply to online transactions. | ||||||||||||
| Annual Admin Fee For Small Accounts | Minimum Account Size | Withdrawal Fees | Transfer-Out Fees | Minimum Stock Trading Commission For Smaller Accounts | Stock-Trading Commission For Large Or Active Accounts | Fees To Buy Or Sell Mutual Funds | ||||||
| BMO InvestorLine (bmoinvestorline.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | $5,000 | $50 | $50/$135 | $29 | $9.95 | none for most funds | |||||
| RRIF | none | $5,000 | none | $50/$135 | ||||||||
| TFSA | $50 | none | none | $50/$135 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $50/$135 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP admin fees waived for accounts of $15,000 more more, TFSA admin fees are waived when your assets at InvestorLine hit $100,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| ~As of March 10, it will take $25,000 in assets to avoid the fee on RRSP and RESP accounts. | ||||||||||||
| ~most funds sold without fees, others with a $35 charge to buy, sell or switch | ||||||||||||
| CIBC Investor’s Edge (investorsedge.cibc.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | none | $50 | $135 | $28.95 | $7.90 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $100 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF admin fee waived for accounts of $25,000 or more; RESP fee wavied at $15,000 | ||||||||||||
| ~FundPlus registered accounts (funds and bonds or GICS only) cost $25 per year to $25,000 | ||||||||||||
| ~the minimum stock trading commission applies if you prepay $395 per year for 50 trades | ||||||||||||
| Credential Direct (credentialdirect.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $50 | none | $50 | $75/$125 | $19 | $9.95 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $50 | none | none | $75/$125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $75/$125 | ||||||||
| RESP | none | none | none | $75/$125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF admin fee waived for accounts of $15,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| ~Admin fees for small RRSPs and RRIFs with funds and bonds/GICs reduced to $25 per year. | ||||||||||||
| Disnat (disnat.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | $1,000 | $25 | $25/$125 | $29 | $9.95 | none for most funds | |||||
| RRIF | $100 | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF, RESP admin fees waived for accounts of $15,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| ~some funds cost $32 to buy, sell or switch | ||||||||||||
| HSBC InvestDirect (investdirect.hsbc.ca) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $50 | none | $75 | $125 | $29 | $9.98 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $50 | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP and RRIF admin fees waived for accounts of $15,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| National Bank Direct (nbdb.ca) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | none | $50 | $135 | $28.95 | $9.95 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $100 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| TFSA | $50 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF and RESP admin fees waived for acccounts of $25,000 or more; TFSA fee cancelled if you have $100,000+ with NBDB, if you generated a trade commission in the past 12 months or hold only National Bank products | ||||||||||||
| Qtrade Investor (qtrade.ca) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $50 | $1,000 | $50 | $125 | $19 | $9.95 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $50 | $1,000 | none | $125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | $1,000 | none | $125 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | $1,000 | $50 | $125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF, RESP admin fee waived for acccounts of $15,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| ~$19 minimum stock-trading commission applies to market orders; limit orders cost $4 extra | ||||||||||||
| Questrade (questrade.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | none | $1,000 | $25 | $25/$125 | $4.95 | $4.95 | $9.95 | |||||
| RRIF | none | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| RESP | none | $1,000 | none | $25/$125 | ||||||||
| RBC Direct Investing (rbcdirectinvesting.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $75 | none | $50 | $135 | $28.95 | $9.95 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $75 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP, RRIF and RESP admin fee waived for acccounts of $25,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| Scotia iTrade (scotiaitrade.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | none | none | $25 | $125 | $19.99 | $9.99 | none | |||||
| RRIF | none | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| RESP | none | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~$9.99 commissions kick in for accounts of $50,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| ScotiaMcLeod Direct (scotiamcleoddirect.com) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | none | $25 | $125 | $28.95 | $14.95 | none | |||||
| RRIF | $100 | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| TFSA | none | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| RESP | $25 | none | none | $125 | ||||||||
| Notes | ||||||||||||
| ~RRSP admin fee waived for acccounts of $25,000 or more | ||||||||||||
| TD Waterhouse (tdwaterhouse.ca) | ||||||||||||
| RRSP | $100 | none | $25 | $135 | $29 | $9.99 | none in most cases | |||||
| RRIF | $100 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
| TFSA | $50 | none | 1 free/year | $135 | ||||||||
| RESP | $50 | none | none | $135 | ||||||||
Follow me on Facebook. I’m at Rob Carrick – Personal Finance.
